Publications
Altbach, Philip A. (ed.) (1995, 2nd edition 1996) Copyright and development: inequality in the
information age. Bellagio studies in publishing. 109 pp. ISBN 0-937033-58-8. US$20. Publisher
information: The Bellagio Publishing Network Secretariat, The Jam Factory, 27 Park End St., Oxford
OX1 1HU, UK.
Fax: +44-865-793-298.
If you think the information explosion is closing the knowledge gap between developed and less
developed countries, you are wrong. International copyright agreements give Third World countries
nothing more than the right to serve as sweatshops for the developed world. In the short collection of
essays contained in this book publishing authorities from India, Africa, China, and America examine
the causes behind lack of knowledge dissemination to the Third World in the particularly crucial book
publishing market. In various ways, the culprit is the copyright laws of the developed world.
As record numbers of less developed nations have subscribed to international copyright agreements,
copyright law gives a publisher global control over its books. The pressure for international copyright
adherence has come from the developed countries, such as America and Britain, where the bulk of
the publishing industry is concentrated. As a result, the Third World must have important educational
materials published abroad at a cost which is often prohibitively expensive. Third World countries
simply do not have the financial resources, and education suffers as a result.
If copyright is the culprit, profit margin is the accomplice. As Henry M. Chakava points out in his
essay, 'International copyright and Africa: the unequal exchange', established publishers are not
inclined to grant licenses to aspiring native publishers since profits are lower and the specter of future
competition looms vaguely in the distance. Left to current international market forces, knowledge will
remain largely the product of the richer countries to the detriment of the poorer ones.
Government action has not effectively addressed market forces. Although international cooperation
has resulted in some changes in copyright law with respect to educational materials, the changes have
largely been cosmetic. A compulsory license available to poorer countries has never been invoked
because of procedural barriers. An international joint committee of the World Intellectual Property
Organization and UNESCO, designed to promote the transfer of copyrights from advanced to
developing countries, quietly withered away. Dina Nath Malhorta, the former chairman of the
committee, notes in his essay: "It became quite clear that this was a wishy-washy affair just to show
that something was being done."
Although they do not provide all the answers, the essays in this book raise critical issues and provide a
useful analytical backdrop from which to examine the causes and effects of global information
inequality and to plan for change.
(Keith Aoki, Associate Professor, University of Oregon School of Law, Eugene, Oregon, USA)
Auliff, Lillian Ann (l997) The evolution of the Yoruba video industry and its potential for
development communications. Studies in Technology and Social Change, No. 27. iv + 135 pp.
ISBN 0-945271-43-3. US$14. Payment must be in US currency with check made out to Iowa State
University; add $3 per copy for postage within the USA and $4 for international orders. Send orders
to CIKARD, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa 50011, USA.
Tel.: +1-515-2940-938.
Fax: +1-515-2946-058.
This study starts from the idea that indigenous media, especially folk media, are effective disseminators
of development information, and from the defi-nition of development set forth by Wang and
Dissanayake (1984) which emphasizes three points: i) development involves the majori-ty of the
population in both its planning and its re-wards; ii) it maintains the natural and cultural environment and
iii) it is a process of change. The study traces the evolution of traditio-nal Yoruba travelling theatre to
the new video industry and exami-nes the already existing developmental messages within Yoruba
videos. The plots of nine videos are described and the contents scrutini-zed for such themes as setting
(primarily middle and/or upper class urban), values (mainly family values and marriage contract
issues), ceremony, ritual, celebration (weddings, funerals), news and social commentary (student riots,
corrupt officers, cleaning up the system) and development issues (gas station opening), the results of
which are presen-ted in 19 tables.
Fieldwork interviews conducted for the study have shown that the majority of the population has
access to videos. The most popular way to see a video is to watch it at someone else's house, where
a 'sociable guy' might play host to some 20 to 30 people. Otherwise, community viewing centers
charge only a very small entrance fee and can seat 50 to 60 people. These audience numbers are far
greater then those ever attracted by traditi-onal travelling theatre perfor-mances. Video is reaching
more people, more quickly.
The study concludes that video offers great potential as a medium for deve-lopment communication
and that indivi-dual producers are already using it for that purpose. It gives 13 recommen-dations for
video for development.
Baerts, Martine, Jean Lehmann, Michel Ansay and Kakule Kasonia (l996) A few medicinal plants
used in traditional veterinary medicine in sub-Saharan Africa: a data bank. l54 pp.
paperback.
Price: for members of the sub-network 'Health, animal production and environment', free-of-charge;
for non-members, US$30; and for nationals of an ACP (African, Caribbean, Pacific) country,
US$20. Published by Louvain University Press for the Centre Technique de Cooperation Agricole et
Rurale (Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation) of the University Louvain-la-Neuve.
Contact address: Madame Martine Baerts-Lehmann, Institut Carnoy, 4 place Croix du Sud, 1348
Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium.
E-mail: lehmann@fynu.ucl.ac.be
Tel.: +32-10-473421.
Fax: +32-10-473471.
This data bank contains listings for thousands of plants, complete with the botanical identification,
diseases the plant is used for, and African countries where it is used for veterinary purposes. There is
also an extensive bibliography. This book is a very important resource for anyone who is interested in
ethnoveterinary medicine and indigenous approaches to the care and management of animals.
(D.M. Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Eyzaguirre, Pablo, and Masa Iwanaga (eds) (1996) Participatory plant breeding. Proceedings of
a workshop on participatory plant breeding, 26-29 July 1995, Wageningen, the Netherlands.
164 pp. ISBN 92-9043-269-1. Free-of-charge. Published by International Plant Genetic Resources
Institute (IPGRI), Via delle Sette Chiese 142, 00145 Rome, Italy.
This important collection of experiences and programmes in farmers' participation in plant breeding
and variety selection is divided into three sections: (l) The global context: breeding and crop genetic
diversity, (2) Farmers managing crop diversity, and (3) farmers and crop breeders as partners. Case
studies from Kenya, India, Philippines, Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania, Colombia, Syria, Brazil, and Peru
cover a continuum from breeder-controlled to farmer-controlled systems of breeding and selection,
and indicate clearly the cost-effectiveness of working with farmers' skills in experimentation and
innovation.
(D.M.Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Furze, Brian, Terry De Lacy and Jim Birckhead (1996) Culture, conservation and biodiversity.
The social dimension of linking local-level development and conservation through protected
areas.
300 pp. £40. Available from John Wiley & Sons, Baffins Lane, Chichester, West Sussex,
PO191UD, UK.
E-mail: gbjwsjs2@ibmmail.com
Tel.: +44-1243843206.
Fax: +44-1243770225.
Culture, conservation and biodiversity brings together the two major issues facing humanity in the next
millennium: ensuring the development needed to support a growing world population while at the same
time protecting the environment. The role and nature of 'protected areas' is at the heart of this
dilemma, since it is clear that they can no longer remain development-free zones, but must come to
terms with ecologically sustainable development activity within and around them. The book uses
comparative case studies of local-level involvement in development activities within the ecologically
sensitive protected areas of Asia, the Americas, Africa, Europe and Australia to illustrate the process
of sustainable environmental management.
Combining development with the conservation of biodiversity requires application of social-science
concepts, methods, techniques and ethics. The book presents and discusses these, and illustrates how
they can be used in real management situations, involving ecotourism and indigenous land
management, for example. It stresses the importance of the genuine participation of local people in
programmes of development and conservation as well as the community management of biosphere
reserves.
The aim of the book is to show how social sciences can provide the framework for drawing links
between the complexities of local-level development and global factors of an economic, ecological,
cultural and political nature.
(Jo Millar, Charles Sturt University, Albury, Australia)
Hasler, Richard (1996) Agriculture, foraging and wildlife resource use in Africa: cultural and
political dynamics in the Zambezi Valley. 208 pp. ISBN 0-7103-0515-X. £45 or US$76.50.
Kegan Paul International, P.O. Box 256, Bedford Court Mansions, Bedford Ave, London WC1B
3SW UK.
E-mail: books@keganpau.demon.co.uk
Throughout most of the 1990s, Zimbabwe has been engaged in a revolutionary experiment in
sustainable wildlife management. The Communal Areas Management Program for Indigenous
Resources, better known as CAMPFIRE, has devolved control away from state to local institutions,
so guaranteeing that economic benefits from wildlife are captured by local people and communities.
Wildlife that once were a problem--for farmers, because they eat and damage agricultural and
pastoral resources--now have a direct value, and so are more likely to be conserved. It sounds good,
but has it worked?
This book presents valuable new evidence from a remote part of the Zambezi valley, where buffalo
and elephants compete with foragers and stream-bank farmers. It describes in detail a wide range of
indigenous practices and knowledge, and discusses how these intersect with external sources of
knowledge and how they have changed over time. Examples of the successful management of wildlife
are put forward, as are examples of efforts that have been thwarted by various vested interests.
It is clear that social heterogeneity and conflicting rights between neighbouring communities, between
safari operators and local wildlife committees, and between different levels of government, are making
the sustainable management of wildlife much more difficult than anyone had anticipated. Understanding
these 'bundles of rights' is crucial if co-management is to work. This book makes an important
contribution to this understanding.
This reviewer's only complaint lies in the price of the book, which places it beyond the reach of most
of the professionals and activists in Africa who are directly involved with these fascinating changes.
This points up a general problem, which might be addressed in two ways. Authors and readers should
put pressure on Northern publishers to make their products available in developing countries for
reduced prices. The other option would be to allow publishers in developing countries to produce
cheaper editions of the same titles, perhaps with the help of a grant.
(Jules Pretty, International Institute for Environment and Development, London, UK)
Hess, Carmen G. (1997) Hungry for Hope: On the Cultural and Communicative Dimensions
of Development in Highland Ecuador. IT Studies in Indigenous Knowledge and
Development.144 pp.
ISBN 1-85339-403-3. £15.95. Published by Intermediate Technology Publications,103/105
Southampton Row, WC1B 4HH, UK.
Fax: +44 171 436 2013.
For the USA: Women Ink, 777 UN Plaza, New York, NY 10017, USA.
Fax: +1 212 661 2704.
This, the fifth volume in the Intermediate Technology Publications series on Indigenous Knowledge
and Development, is based on a detailed study of a rural community in highland Ecuador. An
apparently well planned campaign to rid sheep of their parasites failed because it was a typical
example of 'development from above'. The beliefs and culture of the local sheep-herders were simply
not taken into account. The author presents a detailed description and analysis of local agriculture,
from the perspectives both of the local farmers and of outside developers and scientists; she shows
that these are quite different interpretations of the same reality.
The author concludes with an excellent overview of the relationship between communication and
social change, considering and criticizing the main theories on the subject. The contributions of Paulo
Freire and of Jurgen Habermas are examined in particular detail.
This book will be valuable especially to those studying rural society and development in the Andes. It
will also be found useful by a wider readership interested in the role of indigenous knowledge, the
relationship between development and anthropology, and the significance of communication in
development. Hungry for Hope is an unusual and an important contribution to our understanding of
rural development.
(David Brokensha, Institute for Development Anthropology, New York, USA)
Horn, Gabriel (White Deer of Autumn) (1996) Contemplations of a Primal Mind.166 pp. ISBN
1-880032-55-4. US$ 12.95. Published by New World Library. Distributed by Publishers Group
West, 14 Pamaron Way, Novato, California 94949 USA.
Tel.: +1-800-972-6657.
Fax: +1-415-884-2199.
Gabriel Horn (White Deer of Autumn), formerly a teacher in the American Indian Movement (AIM)
Survival Schools, is a celebrated Native American writer who defines a 'primal person' as one who
lives in harmony with his or her natural environment. He compares the primal person with 'civilized'
peoples who have denigrated all things 'primitive' while seeking power rather than balance, and
subordination rather than sharing in our relationships with each other and with the Earth. White Deer
of Autumn eloquently shares the Native American primal experience and world view through oral
traditions passed down through generations of his own family. Comparing the 'primal mind' with the
'civilized mind', the author provides the 'Primal Manifesto' based on the power of ancestral wisdom.
This is a stunning and revealing look at Native American knowledge that provides the foundation for
contemporary Native American activism. The survival of what White Deer of Autumn calls the Old
Ways is now at stake, even as Native Americans feel the surging resiliency of their ancient wisdom.
(D.M.Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Novaes da Mota, Clarice (1997) Jurema's children in the forest of spirits: healing and ritual
among two Brazilian indigenous groups. IT Series in indigenous knowledge and
development.133 pp. ISBN 1-85339-402-5. Published by Intermediate Technology Publications,
103/105 Southampton Row, London WC1B 4 HH, UK.
Fax: +44-171-436-2013.
For the USA: Women Ink, 777 UN Plaza, New York NY 100178, USA.
Fax: +1-212-661-2704.
This latest volume in the IT Series on IK&D links up neatly with the increasing interest in micro-level
studies of indigenous peoples, and the way their specific perceptions, cosmologies and practices
constitute their cultural heritage, while providing them with a strong 'Leitmotif' for their daily lives. As
the Western philosophy of nature
and the environment is increasingly failing to reverse the process of environmental degradation, much
can be learnt from such indigenous groups as the Kariri and the Shoko of northeastern Brazil, who
retain their unique
interpretation and management of their habitat, despite increasing threats from outside.
The author, who lived and worked among the Kariri-Shoko, provides emic information on the way in
which ethnobotanical knowledge and the use of plants for medicinal and magical purposes not only
has practical utility
for their subsistence, but also strengthens the ethnic identification of the local community.
Following an ethnographic account of the two Indian groups, interspersed with accounts of personal
meetings with a variety of informants and respondents, a good picture is presented of their
ethnohistory and cultural identity. This includes an assessment of the indigenous cosmovision,
presented in the context of rituals, magic, and secrets. The role of the concept of space is represented
by the 'secret' Ouricuri space, composed of three concentric circles within the village. In the rituals
described here, a central role is reserved for Jurema, an important local deity identified with a 'sacred'
plant, and its power to guide the destiny of its followers, the Juremados or Jurema's children.
The true value of this work lies in the description of the local classification of plants, the healers who
possess the knowledge of their use in promoting health and healing, the local health practices, and the
people's perception of illness. These are skilfully analysed against the background of the Kariri-Shoko
universe, and contribute to the strong sense of the cultural identity of both ethnic groups.
Although the author's occasional use of jargon contrasts with the authentic accounts of local
informants, she manages to integrate their illustrative narratives into a sound study of the belief systems
of these and similar forest communities in the region.
The book is well turned out and will be of great interest to scientists and students of indigenous
communities and minority groups in the periphery of our world, and to those researchers who seek to
understand the non-Western philosophical phenomena that help these groups to maintain their often
unique way of life.
(Dr. L. Jan Slikkerveer, LEAD, Leiden University, the Netherlands)
Normann, Hans, Ina Snyman and Morris Cohen (eds) (1996) Indigenous knowledge and its uses
in Southern Africa. vii +158 pp. ISBN 0-7969-1692-6. Rand 40 or US$9. Published by Human
Sciences Research Council, Pretoria, South Africa. Order from Human Sciences Research
Council (with checks made out to same), Private Bag X41, 0001 Pretoria, South Africa.
Tel.: +27-12-202-9111.
Fax: +27-12-326-5362.
The 13 papers in this volume were presented at the conference 'Indigenous Knowledge and
Practice', which was organized by the South African Resource Centre for Indigenous Knowledge and
the Institute for Indigenous Theory and Practice, and held at the South African Museum in Cape
Town on 24 November 1994. Eight of the contributions deal with indigenous therapeutic systems,
two with indigenous agriculture, and two with human and social services.
This is an excellent text that the IK network will find particularly useful.
(D.M. Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Scheer, Steven H. (1996) Communication between irrigation engineers and farmers: the case
of project design in North Senegal. xx + 258 pp. ISBN 90-5485-546-0. Department of Irrigation
and Soil and Water Conservation, Agricultural University of Wageningen, the Netherlands (Thesis
Publishers).
Available from: Scheer Training & Facilitation, E. van Reijdtstraat 8, 7412 EA Deventer, the
Netherlands.
Tel./fax: +31-570-645-714.
This doctoral thesis is the result of several years which the author spent observing the implementation
of irrigation schemes along the Senegal River in West Africa. He was especially interested in the
interface between farmers and design engineers. As an irrigation engineer who has been sensitized to
the importance and relevance of the social sciences in his field of work, the author describes the
difficulties encountered when farmers and engineers have to communicate with each other about
technical aspects of irrigation design and systems operation. He examines in detail the differences of
perpective and perception between the two groups, which are a function of the knowledge systems of
each.
The author examines local farmers' technical knowledge with respect to physical phenomena, and
then explores methods by which participatory design processes could be used to achieve a more
effective exchange of technical knowledge between engineers and farmers. The study shows that while
farmers and engineers have very different perspectives on irrigation, one side seldom learns anything
from the other. The result is that farmers continue their old practices while design engineers continue to
produce new technical designs which are not adapted to the practices of local farmers. In the end, this
mutual lack of adaptation is costly and has a negative impact on sustainability.
The author has tested and reviewed several models for closing this communication gap by activating a
'perpetual learning cycle' between the two groups.
This thesis provides relevant and useful material for development specialists of all disciplines, and
should be of particular interest to anyone concerned with indigenous knowledge systems as they relate
to technology and development.
(Ray Norman, Agriculture Division OCDN2, African Development Bank, Côte d'Ivoire)
Senah, Kodjo Amedjorteh (l995) Money be man: the popularity of medicines in a rural
Ghanaian community. 256 pp. ISBN 90-5589-046-4. US$15. Het Spinhuis, Oudezijds
Achterburgwal l85, 1012 DK Amsterdam.
E-mail: spinhuis@pscw.uva.nl,
Fax: +31-20-525-3010.
This is the first in-depth study of the relationships between the system for classifying diseases used by
the Ga ethnic group of Ghana, and the disease etiologies and treatment linked to the emic perceptions
underlying the use of modern pharmaceuticals. The study presents the comparative attributes of both
indigenous herbal medicines and western pharmaceuticals.
This is an indispensable book for those involved with national health policies and their relationship to
indigenous therapeutic concepts.
(D.M. Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Shiva, Vandana (1996) Protecting our biological and intellectual heritage in the age of
biopiracy.
Paper presented during the seminar 'IPR's, Community Rights and Biodiversity: a new partnership for
national sovereignty', held in New Delhi on 20 February 1996. It can be obtained from the Research
Foundation for Science, Technology and Natural Resource Policy, A-60 Hauz Khas, New Delhi 110
- 016, India.
Dr. Shiva argues that indigenous knowledge related to biodiversity should be well protected against
commercial agencies that operate internationally. She supports her argument with ample evidence
from India. Her examples include the case of neem (Azadirachta indica) seeds, which have long been
in use by local peoples. In recent years a dozen US and Japanese companies have patented
herbicides and other products made from these seeds. According to Dr Shiva, there should in fact be
discussion of the entire ethics of foreign companies coming in, 'using' knowledge that indigenous
peoples have built up--often over long periods, and then patenting the fruits of that knowledge
elsewhere. In this process, the rights of local people are often trodden upon.
The paper offers interesting insights into how this issue is viewed in India. Readers interested in
biodiversity and its management through indigenous systems, and in how indigenous rights should be
protected, will find the paper a valuable contribution.
However, the paper tends to seek solutions mostly at the legal level, whereas a more integrated
approach might have been of more use. A code of conduct for commercial agencies, be they foreign
or national, would be welcome, for example. Moreover, exchanges between IK systems can be
valuable for local people. Even India, with its enormous variety of plants and animals, might be able to
benefit from biological elements brought in from elsewhere in the world. It can be assumed that the
exchange of medicinal plants between neighbouring countries in fact already occurs. Agrodiversity is
not static, but dynamic, and constantly incorporating external elements. Finally, making the assumption
that the positions of North and South are necessarily opposed seldom leads to valuable solutions.
There are parties in the North as well as the South who are urging that multinational companies be
subjected to ethical codes.
The paper would have been more complete if a list of abbreviations and references had been added.
Nevertheless, it remains an interesting and very readable document for anyone interested in the
discussion now going on in India about the protection of biodiversity.
(ir. J. Brouwer, Programme Officer, Netherlands Development Organisation SNV, Cameroon)
Sumberg, James, and Christine Okali (1997) Farmers' experiments: creating local knowledge.
186 pp. ISBN 1-55587-674-9. US$45. Published by Lynne Rienner Publishers, 1800 30th St.,
Suite 314, Boulder, Colorado 80301-1026, USA.
Tel.: +1-303-444-6684.
Fax : +1-303-444-0824.
This is the most comprehensive overview of the literature dealing with indigenous agricultural
experimentation and innovation. The authors also present the empirical data on farmers' experiments
from case studies in Kenya, Zimbabwe, Ghana, and the UK that demonstrate that "farmers'
experiments represent an important and generally undervalued rural development resource."
The central conclusion is "that farmers' experimentation is widespread, an important part of everyday
farming, and shares many characteristics with formal agronomic experimentation. Thus, through their
experiments, farmers are involved in ongoing processes of local knowledge creation through
site-specific learning, which, in the short term, results primarily in small adaptations to farming practice
and, in the long term, contributes to the development of new farming systems. However, we conclude
at the same time that although in many situations the arguments for greater participation of farmers in
agricultural research are compelling and relevant, relatively little potential synergy will be realized
through formal research and farmers' experimentation being more closely linked. In addition, because
of the site-specific nature of the knowledge created through farmers' experiments, the claim that there
is significant unrealized development potential associated with them, which could somehow be used to
make an impact on a larger scale, is also called into question" (7-8).
Chapter 3, 'Farmers' experiments: concepts, evidence, and claims', synthesizes an enormous array of
academic and development literature. This synthesis includes an overview of the characteristics of
farmers' experiments, typologies of farmers' experiments, and factors influencing farmers'
experimentation, who experiments?, links with formal research, farmers' experiments and local
communication systems. The authors conclude that "Both farmers' experiments and much formal
experimentation aim to develop practical solutions to immediate problems or to seek small gains within
the context of proven production methods and systems. Both are largely empirical and iterative,
combining experience, observation (both methodical and opportunistic), intuition, persistence, skill and
luck" (149).
This book provides a theoretical and empirical base from which alternative models for the interaction
of formal research and farmers' experiments can be evaluated.
(D.M. Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Users' Perspectives with Agricultural Research and Development (UPWARD) (l996) Into action
research: Partnerships in Asian rootcrop research and development. xvii + 278 pp. ISBN
971-614-006-1. US$12. Published by UPWARD, Philippines. Order from UPWARD, Box 933,
Manila, Philippines.
E-mail: cip-manila@cgnet.com
Fax: +65-2-891-1291.
This is an excellent compilation of recent case studies relating to collaborative research by farmers and
agricultural researchers. The 19 cases are presented under four headings: the relevance of rootcrop
indigenous knowledge for development; sustaining community action in rootcrop research and
development; enterprise development through participatory research; and development and diffusion
of innovations through institutional linkages. Case studies come from China, the Philippines, Indonesia,
Vietnam, and Nepal.
(D.M. Warren, CIKARD, USA)
Zimmerer, Karl S. (1996) Changing fortunes: biodiversity and peasant livelihood in the
Peruvian Andes. ix + 308 pp. ISBN 0-520-20303-8. US$45 or £35. University of California
Press, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA.
This is a well researched and sophisticated book which dares to tackle the complex task of analyzing
the interrelationships between sustainable development, biodiversity, indigenous knowledge and
peasant survival strategies. It also dares to criticize influential theories in these areas. The author's
underlying message is that only through careful scientific research in specific localities is it possible to
understand the processes involved and thus to design appropriate policies within a participatory and
democratic framework--policies which foster sustainability and biodiversity while improving the lives
of peasants.
Zimmerer is able to dispel many notions about sustainable development that are widely held but
nevertheless wrong. He does this on the basis of his long years of excellent ethnographic field research
among Quechua peasants living from small-scale farming in the mountainous regions of Paucartambo
near Cuzco (Mexico). For example, Zimmerer disputes the arguments that cultural change among an
indigenous population necessarily endangers biodiversity, that high-yield varieties invariably contribute
to genetic erosion, that there is an essential harmony between the native population and nature, and
that increasing commercialization always leads to less diversity in the crops grown.
Instead, Zimmerer argues on the basis of his findings that while some of these relationships do exist
under some circumstances, the picture is far more complex and full of unexpected results than these
relationships would suggest. His general findings do show that the intrusion of agribusiness, of urban
market demand and international food aid have indeed added to the threat to biodiversity posed by
changes in the region. Thus he does not deny that biodiversity in the Peruvian Andes is at risk or that
farm landscapes have been degraded; he does, however, demonstrate that the reasons generally given
to explain these outcomes are either false, inadequate or partial. For example, Zimmerer finds that
some Quechua farmers have improved their living standards through greater market integration and
that this has allowed them to cultivate a greater diversity of crops than Quechua peasants who are
poor in resources. He also discovers that certain technical changes have enhanced the versatility of
intercropping, thereby preventing further loss of biodiversity. Many of these innovations have emerged
from the experience and experimentation of indigenous farmers. Similarly, indigenous communities
have often used outside cultural influences to reinvent and give new cultural meaning to symbols and
practices which have enhanced sustainable development. This is very different from allowing outside
cultural influences to lead to acculturation that is demeaning and ecologically impoverishing.
(Cristóbal Kay, Institute of Social Studies, The Hague, the Netherlands)
Back to: top of the page | Contents IK Monitor 5(2) | IK Homepage
Suggestions to: ikdm@nuffic.nl
(c) copyright Nuffic-CIRAN and contributors 1997.